The “Stop-Doing” List: Why Your New Year Resolution Should Be About Subtraction, Not Addition

We have all been there. It is January 2nd, and you have already “failed.”

You created a list of Goals that required you to learn a new language, maximize your macros, and start a side hustle all before breakfast. But instead of feeling energized, your brain feels like a computer with too many tabs open—a spinning beach ball of death.

If you are serious about your 2026 goals, it is time to stop adding more to your plate. The secret to a fresh start isn’t doing more; it is doing less. By applying the Eisenhower Matrix to your personal life, you can filter out the noise and focus on what matters. Remember: change your mindset change your life, but that mindset shift requires clearing the space to be who you actually are.

In this article, we will break down why traditional resolutions fail and how to use the “Trash-It Matrix” to perform “Strategic Subtraction” on your life.

If you haven’t watched the companion video yet, you can check it out here: Watch ‘The Brutal Truth About New Year Resolutions No One Wants to Hear‘ on YouTube or watch it below…

If you like this type of content, and would like to watch our future videos, please subscribe to the Hey Mindset Matters YouTube channel and ring the notification bell so you’re notified each time we drop a new video. 

The New Year Trap

Most of us fall into the “New Year Trap.” We assume a fresh start means piling on new obligations. We treat willpower as an infinite resource, but as noted in recent behavioral psychology discussions, willpower is finite. Every unnecessary “should” drains the tank.

Think of your resolutions like a backpack full of rocks—composed of old habits, guilt, and performative goals. If you try to climb the mountain of new year 2026 with that weight, you will exhaust yourself before you reach the first base camp.

The Solution: Strategic Subtraction

To succeed, we need to practice “Strategic Subtraction.” This isn’t just about laziness; it is about identifying the best habits to keep and ruthlessly eliminating the rest.

We can do this using a tool called the “Trash-It Matrix,” an adaptation of the famous Eisenhower Matrix.

The Exercise: The Trash-It Matrix

Grab a piece of paper and draw a box divided into four quadrants. This simple exercise will help you separate the signal from the noise.

Quadrant 1: Urgent & Important (Do It Now)

The top-left quadrant is for things that are both urgent and important. These are immediate deadlines, paying rent, or “keeping the cat alive”. These are non-negotiable tasks that require immediate attention.

Quadrant 2: Not Urgent but Important (The Growth Zone)

The top-right quadrant is where we want to live. These are the Smart Goals that drive long-term happiness but don’t scream for attention today.

• Examples: Exercise, deep work, family time, and getting 8 hours of sleep. This is the “Growth Zone.” The danger is that because these tasks aren’t “urgent,” they often get pushed aside by Quadrant 3.

Quadrant 3: Urgent but Not Important (The False Urgency Trap)

This is the bottom-left quadrant, and it is the silent killer of most New Year Resolutions. We call this the “False Urgency Trap”.

• What it feels like: It feels productive. It mimics work.
• What it actually is: Checking emails constantly, arguing with strangers on the internet, or following arbitrary rules because an internet guru told you to.

The “5 AM Club” Example: Consider the common resolution to join the “5 AM Club.” You might place this in Quadrant 1 (Urgent/Important) because you feel like a failure if you miss it. However, if waking up at 5 AM ruins your sleep and leaves you too tired to work by 2 PM, it is actually a net loss.

This is a classic “False Urgency” task. You are doing it out of guilt, not utility. As the CEO of your life, you need to fire the version of yourself that performs these toxic, performative tasks.

Quadrant 4: Not Urgent, Not Important (The Trash)

The bottom-right quadrant is for pure time-wasters—mindless scrolling and guilt-driven activities. The instruction here is simple: eliminate them entirely.

Practical Application: Fire Your “Past Self”

Your challenge for this week is to fill out these four quadrants.

1. Identify the “Shoulds”: Look at your current list of 2026 goals.
2. Spot False Urgency: Find at least one goal you are pursuing solely out of guilt or performative pressure (Quadrant 3).
3. Trash It: Move that item to the trash.

By removing this false urgency, you free up energy for Quadrant 2—the things that actually matter, like getting enough sleep to think clearly.

Final Thoughts

There is nothing in the rulebook that says a fresh mindset is about doing more. It is about clearing the space to be who you actually are.

This year, don’t just make a list of things to start. Make a “Stop-Doing List.” When you change your mindset and change your life, you realize that sometimes the most productive thing you can do is delete a goal that never really belonged to you.

Other articles of interest… 

• Three Deep Focus Exam Prep Strategies That Top Students Use to Increase Productivity (Active Recall, Spaced Repetition & Pomodoro Technique)
• How to Finally Stop Procrastinating: Five Psychology – Backed Strategies That Actually Work  
• The Secret Motivational Trick – Let’s Hack the Formula
• Emotional Intelligence: The Four Core Pillars Explained

If you found this helpful, subscribe for more mindset and motivational videos on our YouTube channel.